March 4, 2014 - Jonah Case Update

FCDF Beats Back SPLC's Attack on Religious Liberty in the JONAH Case:

The depositions of most of the plaintiffs and all of the defendants have now been completed in this landmark case brought against JONAH by the Southern Poverty Law Center ("SPLC"). These depositions reveal that there is indeed fraud involved in this case but it is solely on the part of the SPLC's clients, not the JONAH defendants. Let's look at the plaintiffs' false claims and what the evidence actually shows in this case to date:


Claim 1: Homosexuals Are "Born Gay" 

Comprehensive twin studies show that people are not born gay. Identical twins have the same genetic code, but even when one of them is gay the other usually is not. See link here: Moreover, gay researchers admit no gay gene has ever been found. And even the pro-gay American Psychological Association ("APA"), acknowledges that homosexuality appears to be caused by a complex mix of factors that may include biological influences as well as developmental factors.

These developmental factors often include the perception that the father is abusive or distant, the perception that the mother is overbearing, the incidence of sexual molestation, and/or bullying by other boys in school. This leads to a lack of attachment to their own gender, which results in the envy -- and even mystification -- of other boys. This in turn leads to same sex attraction in the adolescent years. The influence of these various factors is generally involuntary. Of course, the decision to identify as "gay," and to act on those same sex attractions, is voluntary.

Claim 2: Sexual Orientation Cannot Be Changed

JONAH has helped hundreds of men diminish or completely dissipate their unwanted same-sex attractions. It does this through referrals to experienced life coaches and counselors who employ widely used processes that help diminish guilt, shame and envy of other men. As shame and envy diminish, and healthy relationships with other men are developed, the same sex attractions diminish and opposite sex attractions frequently increase. Former clients have come forward to testify as to how JONAH’s program helped them achieve their dreams of having a wife and family and, in some cases, even saved their lives.

Nationwide, there are thousands of men and women that now identify as "ex-gay." The APA notes that for some people homosexuality is fluid and flexible and upholds the time-honored principle that everyone has the right to self-determination. The plaintiffs and SPLC stand against the right of unhappy men and women to choose to seek help for their unwanted same-sex attractions. There is ample scientific evidence that such efforts can be successful. The recent book by James E. Phelan, Successful Outcomes of Sexual Orientation Change Efforts: An Annotated Bibliography, published in January 2014, cites numerous studies that document this change.

JONAH's experience is similar to that of other practitioners of sexual orientation change efforts ("SOCE") and, indeed, therapists who help people overcome other psychological or emotional problems. In that regard, the evidence shows that approximately one-third of people reach their goal of overcoming unwanted same-sex attractions, approximately one-third of people make significant progress towards achieving their goals and experience substantial benefits, and approximately one-third of people do not reach their goals. A new article that contains many good facts and references to counter plaintiffs’ false claims can also be found here:

Claim 3: Homosexual Behavior Is Not Disordered

JONAH does not hold the position that homosexuality is a mental disease or defect. That does not mean, however, that it is not a serious problem for those who are disturbed by their same-sex attractions. Many of these people hold religious beliefs and values that are antithetical to the gay agenda. According to a recent Pew Survey, approximately one-half of the American people believe that homosexual behavior is sinful. The Catholic Catechism states that homosexual attractions are "disordered." The gay activists at the SPLC want to stigmatize and punish people of faith, including the JONAH defendants, who also hold traditional/Biblical views on human sexuality.

Moreover, the plaintiffs and the SPLC refuse to acknowledge the grave warnings of the Center for Disease Control that homosexual behavior leads to serious risks of sexually transmitted diseases, especially HIV/AIDS, which is increasing among teenage boys and young men in their twenties. Even the FDA website indicates that condoms are not designed for sodomy and such unnatural acts can never be considered "safe." A good short discussion of the freedom of speech and religion implications of this issue can be found here:

Conclusion:  None of the Plaintiffs' Claims Are Valid

Not only did all of the plaintiffs fail to complete the defendants' program, but they each admit that there was no guarantee of any particular result. None of them complained while they were still in the program, but rather expressed gratitude for the defendants' efforts. The SPLC's plaintiff-spokesperson, Chaim Levin, had even offered to be a spokesperson and fundraiser for JONAH, and he spoke about the program in the most glowing terms when he was still participating in it.

It was not until some eighteen months after Chaim Levin quit the defendants' program that he was recruited by gay activists to bring this bogus lawsuit. He and the rest of the plaintiffs are merely puppets of the SPLC and militant gay activists. This includes Wayne Besen, a relentless antagonist of the ex-gay community and the chief architect of the present malicious lawsuit against the JONAH defendants. The misguided efforts of the plaintiffs and their handlers, to set-back the cause of religious liberty, are destined to fail.


A regular monthly contribution of just $10 a month will help us fight this publicly announced plan to bankrupt Christians,  Jews, and other believers in this country—can you help? Please visist the FCDF website today at


Defense Fund Coffee Now Available to Support Work of FCDF:


Deacon Mitch Rennix, the generous owner and operator of His Coffee Company has shown his wonderful support for the religious liberty work of the FCDF by introducing a new line of Defense Fund Coffee products. Please visit the new website here to order your Defense Fund Coffee today:

Freedom of Conscience Defense Fund has partnered with His Coffee Company to bring you a coffee an American patriot can feel proud to drink.  We invite you to try a bag of our fairly traded, gourmet, Defense Fund Coffee! Each 12oz. bag is only $15. Five dollars of every bag sold will go directly to FCDF to help offset the ongoing legal fees associated with the trial-level defense for religious and constitutional rights. Defense Fund Coffee comes in Medium Roast, Dark Roast, Decaf and Vanilla Nut. Continue to support FCDF by making Defense Fund Coffee your daily choice for great brew. Sign up today for AutoShip and receive your coffee automatically, when and where you want it. You can also place your order for Defense Fund Coffee through the FCDF website at


donate button

Please Support Our Work:
For more information about our work defending your conscience rights, please visit the FCDF website at  If you wish to support the important work of FCDF, you can do so through the "Donate/Pledge" tab. Please support the work of the FCDF to help us preserve the precious blessings of liberty for our children and grandchildren.
With any donation of $75.00 or more you will get a copy of Charles LiMandri's eye-opening CD set, recorded by Catholic Answers, entitled: "Goodbye Religious Liberty: How the Attacks on Marriage Are Threatening Your Religious Freedom."

Much of the cost of operating the FCDF is being underwritten by the Law Offices of Charles S. LiMandri.  This is a civil litigation practice which has been providing excellent legal services to clients for over 25 years in cases involving business and contract disputes, insurance matters, serious personal injury claims, and real estate litigation. For more information please visit the Law Offices of Charles S. LiMandri at

Forward this e-mail to family, friends and colleagues!

Freedom of Conscience Defense Fund
P.O. Box 9520
Rancho Santa Fe, CA 92067
Tel: (858) 759-9948; Fax: (858) 759-9938